Which hair dye??? need help???? please?

i really need to know which hair dye is the BEST for me and can't choose between these two:

1: punky

http://www.folica.com/Jerome_Russell__d8...

2: manic amplified

http://www.folica.com/Manic_Panic_Amp_d2...

thnx...i would really appreciate it if some1 took their time in looking at the reviews as well to see which is better...

and some details about me:

i have black hair and currently have red dyes that are fading...

light tannish skin and i will bleach my hair for this...

i would also appreciate it if some1 could figure out the pros and cons of it like...LEAKING...and see which is BETTER

THNX so much...i need to know which is better b4 my hair dye fades...and also because of picture day!!

Which hair dye??? need help???? please?

use special effects